Visit our new website:

What Do Index Funds Have to Do With the Cost of Air Travel?

  • Sun, 13 Aug 2017 07:28

Photo credit: xlibber, CC BY 2.0.

The Atlantic just posted a longread titled “Are Index Funds Evil?” which is the kind of question that you know will be answered with “although we’ve found one negative aspect to index funds, overall they’re still solid investments.”

And that’s pretty much what the article delivers.

The negative aspect, in this case, is the cost of air travel.

In April 2014, [José Azar, Martin Schmalz, and Isabel Tecu] posted an early draft of a paper titled “Anti-competitive Effects of Common Ownership.” The paper made several astonishing claims. Overall, it said, the high concentration of share ownership had caused serious harm to consumers in the airline industry: Ticket prices were as much as 12 percent higher than they otherwise would have been, because of common ownership of shares.

Wait, what do you mean by “common ownership?”

The paper noted that three mutual-fund families—BlackRock, State Street, and Vanguard—collectively control about 15 percent of the shares of major U.S. airlines, although these funds are by no means the only common owners.

Got it. Is this… like, can you prove that common owners are driving up airline ticket prices?

The obvious question, of course, is how, exactly, common ownership would encourage these ills. Would common owners actually pressure company managers to collude and raise prices? Would those managers, facing less investor pressure, simply stop competing so hard with one another, enjoying fat paychecks and allowing prices to float up and cost-saving innovation to wither? And would any of that plausibly happen when index funds own just 15 percent of an industry?

The article is dense with both detail and technical terms, and it doesn’t draw a lot of conclusions—except that this type of common ownership might lead to higher airfare, although other factors, like airline mergers, might also be involved.

So index funds are probably not evil. Air travel, on the other hand, is getting worse all the time.

The Billfold


US Weekly

Related Stories

Tim Roxborogh's travel bugs: Muffled departure lounge announcements
  • Wed, 17 Jan 2018 09:25

A weekly ode to the joys of moaning about your holiday, by Tim Roxborogh. It's 2018 and there's no excuse. I'm not talking about tinpot airports in Th...

U.S. companies list blockchain ETFs as bitcoin proposals languish
  • Wed, 17 Jan 2018 08:27

NEW YORK (Reuters) - Investors looking to profit from excitement surrounding bitcoin technology will get a new opportunity this week. Reuters: Mone...

A Tuesday Chat About Dogecoin
  • Wed, 17 Jan 2018 05:28

The Indicator (from Planet Money) is my new favorite podcast — so informative, and so short! — and even though I want to tell you to listen to all...

Waitrose hit as Verifone payment system crashes
  • Wed, 17 Jan 2018 04:28

The supermarket chain has apologised after a system failure left customers unable to pay by card. BBC News - Business

Carillion was left with just £29m before going bankrupt
  • Wed, 17 Jan 2018 03:28

Carillion held rescue talks with the government since October in a bid to stave off collapse, says boss. BBC News - Business

Snow disrupts travel and closes schools in NI
  • Wed, 17 Jan 2018 03:22

Hazardous conditions lead to disruption on bus and rail services, with roads and schools closed. BBC News - Northern Ireland

Walmart Is Reportedly Firing 3,500 Co-Managers
  • Tue, 16 Jan 2018 23:27

Photo credit: Mike Mozart, CC BY 2.0. So the Walmart thing got even worse. As Bloomberg explains: A day after embarking on a pay hike, Wal-Mart Store...

Sub delays could lead to multi-billion-dollar cost blowout, senator warns
  • Tue, 16 Jan 2018 22:39

The cost of Australia's Future Submarine program is likely to blow out by billions of dollars because it is already missing key deadlines, a former de...

Round Hill, investor in Beatles and Bruno Mars songs, raises new fund
  • Tue, 16 Jan 2018 21:30

(Reuters) - Round Hill Music Royalty Partners, a private equity firm which invests in the copyright of songs from artists such as The Beatles, The Rol...

Hacks on how to travel solo this year featured in new guidebook
  • Tue, 16 Jan 2018 21:16

In response to the rising interest in solo travel, Lonely Planet has released a new guidebook that offers up advice on everything from the most solo t...

UK inflation rate drops back to 3%
  • Tue, 16 Jan 2018 17:28

The rate fell from November's six-year high of 3.1% mainly because of the impact of air fares. BBC News - Business

Cash-rich real estate funds in Beijing want to spend, but opportunities are few
  • Tue, 16 Jan 2018 16:43

Real estate private equity funds in Beijing flushed with cash are finding themselves in a bind, as there is too much capital chasing too few viable in...

News Categories